Download Word '97 file now (In Win Zip Format: File Report.zip)

Download Powerpoint Presentation now (In Win Zip Format: File Present.zip)
 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1 ANALYSIS OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORT INDUSTRY

1.1 INTRODUCTION
1.2 LOCATION OF SOFTWARE COMPANIES
1.3 DOMESTIC SOFTWARE INDUSTRY
1.4 SOFTWARE EXPORT INDUSTRY
1.5 STRUCTURE OF SOFTWARE EXPORTS
1.6 DESTINATION OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS
1.7 DEVELOPMENT FOCUS OF THE SOFTWARE EXPORTERS
1.8 MARKETING CHANNELS USED BY SOFTWARE COMPANIES
1.9 SEGMENTS OF APPLICATION SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT
1.10 DEVELOPMENT PLATFORM
1.11 TOP TWENTY SOFTWARE EXPORTERS
2 CHARACTERISTICS OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS
2.1 UNEVEN OUTPUT: SERVICES NOT PACKAGES
2.2 UNEVEN EXPORT DESTINATION: US DOMINATION
2.3 UNEVEN DIVISIONS OF LABOUR: 'BODY SHOPPING PRISON'
2.3.1 Uneven Locational Divisions: Onsite and Offshore Work
2.3.2 Uneven Skill Divisions: Dominance of Programming
2.3.3 Persistence of Onsite Programming Services
2.4 UNEVEN MARKET SHARE: ECONOMIC CONCENTRATION OF PRODUCTION
2.5 UNEVEN SITING: LOCATIONAL CONCENTRATION OF PRODUCTION
3 ANALYSIS OF OTHER SOFTWARE EXPORTING COUNTRIES:
3.1 AUSTRALIA
3.1.1 Effect of East Asian Crisis in Software exports of Australia
3.1.2 Implications for India
3.2 IRELAND
3.2.1 Focus on Exports
3.2.2 People with skills
3.2.3 Focus for Investment
3.2.4 Technology in place
3.3 FINLAND
4 INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS - EVOLUTION & STATE POLICIES
4.1 INTRODUCTION
4.2 A BRIEF HISTORY IN TIME - SOFTWARE POLICY PRIOR TO 1984
4.3 1984-1990: GUIDED AND GUARDED LIBERALISATION
4.4 INDUSTRY EVALUATION OF SOFTWARE POLICY IN 1990
4.4.1 Appropriateness of policy's objectives
4.4.2 Altering the composition of Software Exports
4.4.3 Nature of liberalisation, government support or other policy changes required
4.5 ECONOMIC LIBERALISATION - 1991 - 1998
4.6 PM'S IT TASK FORCE - THE NEW IT POLICY OF THE GOVERNMENT
4.6.1 Info Infrastructure drive
4.6.2 Target ITEX-50
4.6.3 IT for all by 2008
4.6.4 Data Security Systems and Cyber Laws
4.7 CONCLUSIONS
5 CONCLUSIONS
6 REFERENCES
 

TABLE OF TABLES AND FIGURES

TABLE 1.1: GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION OF INDIAN SOFTWARE COMPANIES 6
FIGURE 1.1: GROWTH OF THE DOMESTIC SOFTWARE INDUSTRY 6
FIGURE 1.2: GROWTH OF SOFTWARE EXPORTS FROM INDIA 7
FIGURE 1.3: PERCENTAGE GROWTH OF SOFTWARE EXPORTS FROM INDIA 8
TABLE 1.2: STRUCTURE OF SOFTWARE EXPORTS 9
TABLE 1.3: BREAK UP OF THE SOFTWARE ACTIVITY 9
FIGURE 1.4: DEVELOPMENT FOCUS OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS 10
FIGURE 1.5: A BREAK-UP OF THE MARKETING CHANNELS USED BY INDIAN SOFTWARE COMPANIES 11
FIGURE 1.6: A BREAK-UP OF THE REVENUES BY SECTOR 12
FIGURE 1.7: A BREAK-UP OF THE DEVELOPMENT PLATFORMS USED 12
TABLE 1.4: TOP 20 INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTERS 13
FIGURE 2.1: DESTINATION OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS 16
TABLE 2.1: LOCATION OF INDIAN SOFTWARE COMPANY HEADQUARTERS 20
TABLE 3.1: THE OTHER TOP EXPORTING ORGANISATIONS IN AUSTRALIA 21
FIGURE 3.1: A PROFILE OF SOFTWARE EXPORTS OF IRELAND 22
FIGURE 3.2: A PROFILE OF IRISH SOFTWARE EXPORTS 23
FIGURE 3.3: A COMPARISON OF IRISH EXPORT AND INDIGENOUS SOFTWARE INDUSTRY 24
FIGURE 3.4: DESTINATION OF IRISH SOFTWARE EXPORTS 24
TABLE 3.2: REVENUES OF IRISH SOFTWARE INDUSTRY 24
TABLE 3.3: EXPORTS (AS A % OF TOTAL REVENUE) 25
FIGURE 3.5: COMPOSITION OF IRISH IT INDUSTRY: 25
 
 

1 ANALYSIS OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORT INDUSTRY

1.1 Introduction

Currently, the software industry in India is worth Rs. 63.1 billion (US $ 1.75 billion). If we add in-house development of the large commercial/corporate end-users, then the total software industry is close to Rs. 80 billion or US $ 2.2 billion, whereas ten years back the software industry in India was not more than Rs.300 million or US $10 million.

The Indian software industry has a unique distinction in that most of its output is exported. Of the turnover worth US $2 billion, over 50 per cent is accounted by exports. The CAGR (Compounded Annual Growth Rate) for the Indian software industry in the last five years has been 52.6%. CAGR for the software export industry has been 55.04% while that for the domestic industry has been 48.9%.

Despite these high growth rates, India's share in the world software market is very low, but India still enjoys an advantage over some of the other nations, which are trying to promote software exports. This is due to the fact that India possesses the world's second largest pool of scientific manpower which is also English speaking. Coupled with the fact that the quality of Indian software is good and manpower cost is relatively low, it provides India a very good opportunity in the world market.

1.2 Location of software companies

The industry is mainly concentrated around Metros. Lately, Hyderabad, Chennai, Pune and Gurgaon have emerged as fast growing Software cities. At the same time Bangalore and Mumbai continue to attract investment in software sector. An analysis of the headquarters of the top 430 software companies demonstrated the following statistics.
 
City
No. of Companies
Mumbai
115
Bangalore
87
Delhi, Gurgaon & Noida
70
Hyderabad
37
Chennai
51
Calcutta
25
Pune
23
Others
22
Table 1.1: Geographic location of Indian Software Companies

1.3 Domestic Software Industry

For years, no reliable date has been available on the Indian domestic software industry. This is more so because the percentage of in-house development of software is very high and it is difficult to accurately estimate its value, in1996-97. The domestic software industry has been estimated at Rs.24.1 billion and this does not include the in-house development of software industry has shown a CAGR of 48.9% which has been steadily improving in the last few years.

The growth rate was 44.13% in the year 1996-97. The domestic software industry is expected to gross Rs.36 billion in 1997-98. With the amendments to the copyright Act and its rigorous enforcement, it is expected that in the coming years, piracy would be brought under further control. Also, the government has announced zero import duty on software. With the copyright amendments and zero import duty, the domestic market is expected to show high growth rates in the range of 40-50 percent in the coming years.


Figure 1.1: Growth of the Domestic Software Industry

1.4 Software Export Industry

The Indian software export industry continues to show impressive growth rates. In terms of Indian rupees, the CAGR has been as high as 55.04%. The industry exported software worth Rs.30 billion in 1985 and within a few years, the turnover has grown multifold. In 1996-97, a total export of US $ 1085 million (Rs.39 billion) was achieved and it is expected to be worth US $ 1.8 billion in the current year (1997-98).

Interestingly, most of the export is in the form of providing software services, that is developing or helping develop software for organisations overseas. Most of domestic turnover comes through selling of software products developed primarily in other countries. That is, the overseas revenue is earned by providing services while the domestic revenue comes mostly through trading.


Figure 1.2: Growth of Software Exports from India

The Indian software industry has generated an estimated software export revenue of Rs 3,074 crore (US $853.89 million) in the first half of fiscal 1997-98. The industry has marked a record growth of 64.4 percent over the previous year’s Rs 1,870 crore (US $519.44 million) during the same period.

The software industry in Indian expects to reach an export level of US $ 4.0 billion by 2000 AD For achieving this velocity of business, the industry needs further liberalisation of the Indian economy, simplification of procedures, deployment of additional resources for technical manpower development, new marketing channels and providing state-of-the-art infrastructure for software development.


Figure 1.3: Percentage Growth of Software Exports from India

1.5 Structure of Software Exports

There has been a shift towards offshore services in the software export cargo of India. The bulk of Indian software exports have been in the form of professional services. A detailed analysis indicates that majority of software exports are in the areas classified as "customized" or "professional consultancy". However, since last two years, there has been a visible shift towards off shore project development, which also includes offshore package development has increased to over 41% during the year. Reasons attributed for this growth are increasing number of Software Technology Parks, liberalised economic policy and unnatural visa restrictions by U.S. and some Western European countries

The degree of on-site development is still very high, with as much as 59% of the work being done at the client's site, but it is expected to decrease further in the coming years with improved data communication links. In 1988, the percentage of on-site development was almost as high as 90%.
 

Type of Services
RS. Million
Percentage
On-Site Services
22890.00
58.7%
Offshore Services
11780.00
30.2%
Offshore Packages
4330.00
11.1%
Total
39000.00
100 %

Table 1.2: Structure of Software Exports

A break-up of the software activity is shown in the table below:
 

Software Activity
Domestic Software
 
Software Export
 
 
Rs. Million
% of Total
RS. Million
% of Total
Turnkey
9855
40.9%
-
-
Professional Services
-
-
18213
46.7%
Products & Packages
11270
46.8%
4330
11.1%
Consultancy & Training
1675
6.9%
10685
27.4%
Data Processing
1250
5.2%
4290
11%
Others
50
0.2%
1482
3.8%
Total
24100
100%
39000
100%
Table 1.3: Break up of the Software Activity

An analysis of break-up of software activity of both domestic as well as export industry demonstrates that Products & Packages tops the list with a share of 46.8% in domestic market, whereas professional services command a share of almost 46.7% in the export market.
 

1.6 Destination of Indian Software Exports

In 1996-97, India exported almost 58% of its total software exports of USA and 21% to Europe. The six OECD countries (USA, Japan, UK, Germany, France and Italy) together have 73% of the market share of the world-wide software market. Interestingly, India's exports to these countries are also almost 83% of its total software exports.

In the coming years, India is expected to strike many joint ventures and strategic alliances in Europe. The trade with European nations is growing rapidly. There have been alliances to create more co-operation between Indian and European software companies.

NASSCOM under the aegis of Ministry of Commerce, Government of India had initiated a Project called NASSCOM's India-Europe Software Alliance (NIESA). The NIESA Phase-I was partly funded under the ECIP Facility 1 Scheme of the Commission of the European Communities. After successful completion of phase I of the Project, Nasscom has now launched phase II. This is expected to further help in increasing software exports to Europe.

Over the next two years, software exports to many Asian countries and Australia are also expected to increase. The new markets include Korea, South Africa, Latin America and some countries in Asia-Pacific. USA continues to be India's largest export market. However, if the visa situation for the US market does not improve, the export growth for the US market can be adversely affected.

1.7 Development focus of the Software Exporters

Nearly two thirds of the companies are engaged in developing end-user application products and services ranging from straightforward accounting systems to specialised niche market products or customised services. The rest obtain their revenues from consultancy, systems integration, supply of specialised software systems, such as software tools, communications software and software for dedicated hardware devices.

Figure 1.4: Development Focus of Indian Software Exports

1.8 Marketing channels used by software companies

Marketing is the most critical issue for the development of the Indian software Industry. The size of the Indian software export industry is very small compared to the world market. To emerge as a major player in the world software market, there has to be a significant expenditure on marketing. In India, the software vendors operating in the export market have traditionally depended upon direct marketing to end-users. However lately, many software companies have set up their own offices in various countries.

Figure 1.5: A break-up of the Marketing Channels used by Indian Software Companies

1.9 Segments of Application Software Development

Indian software companies mainly concentrate on developing application software for three main sectors. They include
  1. Banking
  2. Manufacturing
  3. Insurance and Other Financial Services
A segment wise break up of the software industry's revenue demonstrated the following statistics:

Figure 1.6: A break-up of the Revenues by Sector

1.10 Development Platform

Majority of companies concentrate on four major development platforms - PC (DOS, Windows, Apple), Mainframe, UNIX and Midrange. Also, as most companies develop on more than one platform, therefore the values shown total more than 100%. The most common combinations are Unix with PC, and Unix with Midrange.

Figure 1.7: A break-up of the development Platforms used

1.11 Top twenty Software exporters

There are currently more than 550 companies in India which are engaged in the business of software exports. In 1996-97, more than 52 companies have exported more than RS 100 million worth of software. In 1991-92, only five companies and exported software more than RS 100 million. Also in 1996-97, 17 companies exported more than RS 500 million worth of software. This indicates the high proliferation and all-around growth of software exports. The top twenty software exporters (in order of revenue) accounted for almost 60% of the total software exports. The following table lists the Top 20 software exporters by revenue.
 
Rank
Company
Exports 1996-97 in Rs Million
01
Tata Consultancy Services
6068.80
02
Wipro Ltd.
2588.40
03
NIIT Limited
1612.50
04
Pentafour Software & Exports Ltd.
1594.26
05
Infosys Technologies Ltd
1267.10
06
Tata Infotech Limited
1060.00
07
Satyam Computer Services Limited
891.80
08
International Computers (India) Limited
850.20
09
Patni Computer Systems Pvt. Ltd.
848.90
10
DSQ Software Limited
803.99
11
Mahindra British Telecom Limited
799.62
12
Silverline Industries Limited
720.22
13
Tata IBM Limited
648.80
14
CMC Limited
620.94
15
Mastek Limited
578.80
16
Siemens Information Systems Limited
554.10
17
L&T Information Technology Limited
499.30
18
Info. Management Resources(I) Ltd.
497.74
19
Hexaware InfoSystems Limited
483.50
20
Citicorp Info. Technology Industries
470.00
Table 1.4: Top 20 Indian Software Exporters

2 CHARACTERISTICS OF INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS

2.1 Uneven Output: Services not Packages

Indian software exports have been dominated by export of software services, in the form of custom software work, rather than export of software products, in the form of packages. This helps explain the recent rise in growth rates. This rise has partly taken place because of the explosion of services work on the 'Year 2000 problem'; now estimated to make up nearly 40% of current software export work from India. By contrast, at the very most, just under 5% of exports came from packages in 1997/98.

One reason why packages not taken off despite India's low labour cost advantages is because of high entry barriers despite the low cost at which Indian companies can develop such packages.

These entry barriers are lack of familiarity with the foreign package markets they seek to penetrate, and their distance from those markets makes it hard to keep up with changing needs and standards. Moreover, the Indian domestic market is a poor guide for software developers because of differences in user needs, in work, in hardware environments, and a generally low level of innovation.

Other entry barriers in the software package markets is high costs in advertising and marketing effort needed to catch the attention of potential customers. Software multinationals can spend 40-50% of annual revenue on package sales and marketing, and 10-15% on research and development for packages (Economist 1994). For a single large firm, this can represent billions of US dollars-worth of investment: more than the entire output of all Indian software producers.

Due to India's lack of reputation as a software package source and its lack of any software brand names in a relatively brand-loyal market, high sales would not be expected, making the unit cost of marketing and distribution even higher. Providing
support, maintenance and upgrades for a product in a foreign market is also either difficult or very costly.

Lastly, all this assumes success with the product, yet experience suggests that only about 1-5% of software packages succeed, in which case huge investments are required, which are not readily available within India. Even if available, neither government policy nor managerial attitudes have generally encouraged the high-risk, long-term investments necessary.

Because of these constraints, some Indian companies have agreed to undertake custom software work at cut price for a foreign client on the understanding that they will subsequently try to market the developed system as a package for a niche market.
Firms and official surveys frequently classify this as 'package exports' but such 'packages' - sometimes more accurately identified as 'semi-packaged software' - often end up being used merely as marketing or development platforms for further
customisation.

The alternative option for Indian exporters seeking to work on packages is to collaborate with a foreign firm which will supply the package specifications, marketing, support and finance. The drawback is that the Indian company ends up just supplying programming services in return for a very small share of any revenue. Nor will its reputation be much-enhanced for, as with original equipment manufacturing in other fields, the product will emerge under the foreign firm's brand name.
 

2.2 Uneven Export Destination: US Domination

Indian companies have exported software to more than forty countries but there is a heavy reliance on the US market as the figure below indicates.

Figure 2.1: Destination of Indian Software Exports

The US market dominates Indian software exports partly because it is by far the world's largest software market, constituting around half of all software sales in the 1990s. The US has also had more liberal immigration rules for work or residence than most other developed countries which encourages export of onsite projects.

The US-orientation of exports might present a limitation to future growth because US share of the world market is slowly declining. However, the American market is still expanding substantially in absolute terms plus, since the early 1990s, Indian software exports have shown their ability to grow in other markets, such as those of Asia and Europe.
 

2.3 Uneven Divisions of Labour: 'Body Shopping Prison'

2.3.1 Uneven Locational Divisions: Onsite and Offshore Work

Much of India's export work developing custom software is actually carried out at the client's site overseas ('onsite') rather than offshore in India. Back in 1988, an average of 65% of export contracts were carried out wholly at the client site, while 35% contained some offshore elements (Heeks 1991). This translated into just under 75% of Indian software export development taking place overseas and only 25% in India. This was even true of work in India's export processing zones,which were intended to be bases for offshore work.

Subsequent surveys have shown that the amount of work carried out offshore has increased within individual firms.

2.3.2 Uneven Skill Divisions: Dominance of Programming

During the period 1988-1998, at least 65% of export contracts were solely for programming work billed on a 'time and materials' basis, with programming figuring strongly in the remaining one-third of contracts. So, in general terms, India's software export trade has been characterised by an international skill division of labour such
that the majority of software contracts allocate only the less-skilled coding and testing stages to Indian workers. That is to say, Indian workers have far more often been used as programmers, working to requirements and design specifications set by foreign software developers, rather than as systems analysts or designers.In the Indian context, the combination of onsite and programming work has come to be known as 'body shopping'. Amongst other things, this has helped to reinforce a further gender division of labour.

2.3.3 Persistence of Onsite Programming Services

Reasons for onsite programming services are as follows:

2.4 Uneven Market Share: Economic Concentration of Production

Production of Indian software exports is a heavily concentrated. By 1998, there were about 400-500 software export firms. Most, however, are single-contract firms employing just a handful of staff. By contrast, the top five firms were responsible for more than 40% of all exports, and the top twenty for 70% (Dataquest 1998).

Large firms have dominated software exports thanks to the economies of scale and entry barriers that exist in software production. Economies of scale and barriers include those of hardware, of staff training, of marketing and, less tangibly, of credibility and reputation.

Since Indian software exports are services rather than goods, examples cannot easily be displayed to potential buyers to establish credibility. There is therefore a heavy reliance on reputation, track record, references and the skills and appearance of
the marketing team, which all go together to determine the Indian firm's credibility. All these credibility-related factors, which principally hinge on track record and spending on marketing, obviously work to the advantage of larger, longer-established
firms.

The only short cut occurs if a new firm is set up by an ex-member of one of the large IT companies. In this case the individual can make use of his or her personal contacts and credibility. However, this does not enable the firms to overcome technology, skills and finance barriers. This explains their initial reliance on onsite programming services, for which there are few scale economies, and the fact that few of them have made significant long-term headway in software exports.

There are also biases against small and start-up companies in terms of obtaining foreign collaborations and technology, and in dealing with the bureaucracy. For example, despite the falling real prices of powerful computers and telecommunications, these technologies remain beyond the reach of many small Indian firms. Similarly, access to government support tends to be the preserve of the larger firms.

2.5 Uneven Siting: Locational Concentration of Production

Software companies are not distributed evenly throughout India, but are mainly located around a few major Indian cities, especially around Bangalore. Table 3 indicates the location of company headquarters for over 550 software companies
(including a number focused on the domestic market).
 
City
No. of software firms
Bangalore
152
Mumbai
122
Madras
93
New delhi
86
Hyderabad
34
Calcutta
27
Pune
22
Other
22
Total
558
Table 2.1: Location of Indian Software Company Headquarters

Haug's (1991) work has shown that five main factors play a part in the locational decisions of new software companies. One of these - proximity to customers - is of limited relevance in the context of software exports. Three other factors, however, are found to have guided locational decisions in India:

3 ANALYSIS OF OTHER SOFTWARE EXPORTING COUNTRIES

3.1 Australia

Australian exports of products and services are worth over $2.1 billion which shows an increase of more than 10% over last year. Professional Services was the area that generated the greatest revenue (34%). The areas of greatest growth in the last 12 months, were Telecommunications Products (an increase of 83%) and Software (an increase of 79%).

IBM Australia was the highest ranked IT&T exporter (29% of the total exports) with export revenue of $601m in the financial year 1996-97.
 

Organizations
Turnover
NEC Australia
$66.6m
CSC Australia
$58.3m
Mincom
$57m
Fujitsu Australia
$54.4m
Unisys Australia
$49.8m
Canon Australia
$41.15m
Table 3.1: The other top exporting organisations in Australia

3.1.1 Effect of East Asian Crisis in Software exports of Australia

84% of companies active in the region reported suffering adverse affects from the current crisis. However, devaluation of the Australian dollar has resulted in increased price competitiveness for some Australian products that compete with products from other markets, moreover the crisis has assisted as customers are now looking for added efficiencies to save costs by importing software solutions.

Malaysia was the most important market for Australia. The next most important markets are Indonesia, Singapore and Korea, Hong Kong and Thailand. Many organisations have changed their strategies as a result of the economic situation in Asia. The main changes can be summarised as follows:

3.1.2 Implications for India

The above analysis shows that Australian exports will be targeted more towards the North American and European nations and India can face stiff competition especially after the South East Asian crisis.

3.2 Ireland

The software industry is firmly established in Ireland. The domestic sector has innovated a broad rang of products business applications, software tools, advanced telecommunications multimedia systems. In tandem with the development of the indigenous sector, an equally strong overseas sector has chosen Ireland as an offshore software location. Internationally, Ireland is now recognised as a prime source of high quality software development services and as the ideal gateway to European markets.

Figure 3.1: A Profile of Software Exports of Ireland
The reasons behind this booming development include: the availability of a workforce, which is predominantly young, skilled and well educated, with strong technological and business skills; a highly efficient and cost-effective, world-wide communications infrastructure using state-of -the-art technology.

The software sector currently comprises more than 550 companies, 80% of which are Irish owned. Some are small, specialised firms operating at the forefront of software development technologies; others are larger organisations that have successfully targeted niche markets on a worldwide basis and have established offices overseas.

3.2.1 Focus on Exports

Ireland's small domestic market means that substantial growth is often only attainable by servicing the needs of international markets. From the outset, Irish software companies, anxious to exploit overseas markets, develop a unique international orientation that is reflected in the quality and functionality of their products. As a consequence, more than 80% of all indigenous developers are active in overseas markets.

Figure 3.2: A Profile of Irish Software Exports
Annual output from the sector in 1995 was estimated to be worth just under $5 Billion, almost all of which was exported. Indeed, today over 40% of all PC packaged software (including 60% of business application software) sold in Europe is produced in Ireland.

Ireland's indigenous software developers have a uniquely international focus and a strong product bias, setting it apart from many other European countries, where services account for a large proportion of software activity. More than two thirds of Irish companies are involved in developing and/or marketing software products.


Figure 3.3: A Comparison of Irish Export and Indigenous Software Industry

After the U.S., Ireland exports more software than any other country in the world, not on a per capita basis, but in absolute terms! The major destinations for Irish software exports are given below:


Figure 3.4: Destination of Irish Software Exports

Revenue [IR£ million]

 
1991
1993
1995
Indigenous Companies
291
336
390
Overseas Companies
74
81
93
Total
365
417
483
Table 3.2: Revenues of Irish Software Industry


1991 1993 1995
Indigenous Companies 41% 49% 58%
Overseas Companies 98% 98% 99%
Table 3.3: Exports (As a % of total revenue)


Figure 3.5: Composition of Irish IT Industry:

3.2.2 People with skills

The key to Ireland's success in the software business has been the continued availability of young, well-educated people. Ireland has a unique demographic profile - 50% under 28 years of age. A United Nations study shows that by the year 2000, 40% of Ireland's population will be under 25 years of age, significantly ahead of all other countries in Europe. Unlike many countries therefore, Ireland is in a strong position to respond to the growing shortage of IT skills around the world, and is doing so aggressively.

As enthusiastic Europeans, the Irish have a strong work ethic. This is reflected in the rate of employee turnover, which is well below the European average. It means that companies enjoy greater commitment from their staff, and benefit from a higher proportion of experienced personnel and lower annual training costs. Surveys from organisations such as the London consultancy William M. Mercer show that foreign investors in Ireland consider the quality and the 'can do' flexible attitude of Irish people to be two of the country's greatest advantages.

Ireland is committed to further developing the software industry and continues to take steps to ensure that the availability of graduates coming through the country's 20+ universities and third level colleges is sufficient to meet the demands of the sector. Close co-operation between industry and academia has resulted in the provision of additional resources and places for computing courses and also in the establishment a number of new software-related courses - with a greater emphasis on the linguistic skills of graduates and the newer software and telecommunications technologies.

The education system is highly-rated - a recent report by the International Institute for Management Development ranked it the best in Europe - and is ideally geared to producing skilled employees for the software sector.

3.2.3 Focus for Investment

Public investment in software development companies over an extended period of time has been largely indirect, but highly significant in making this one of the fastest growing sectors of the economy. Tax incentives, and grants for employment, capital investment, training and research and development have contributed to attracting over 100 foreign companies to set up operations in this sector which achieve annual revenue growth in of over 25%.

3.2.4 Technology in place

The services provided by both Irish and international companies operating in this area include translation and localisation, disk and CD ROM manufacturing, mastering and duplication, user manual printing, packaging, turnkey and fulfilment services and technical support.

Ireland's digital telecommunications system is one of the most advanced in the world and enables software developers to link across the world for real-time development activities, and provides for pan-European and world-wide customer support.

The transformation of the telecommunications infrastructure has come about as a result of the investment of $5 Billion by Telecom Ireland in the development of fully integrated digital network. Over 75% of all customers are now connected to digital exchanges, which in turn are interconnected by digital transmission systems.
 

3.3 Finland

The growth rate of the finnish software industry has been 60% in 1997 The level of software export is still low, only FIM 500 million in 1997. It is about four per cent of the total IT revenue in Finland.

There are about 420 software companies in Finland out of which most of them are local service companies and do not have software products for international markets. The revenue of software product business was FIM 3.5 billion in 1997.
 

4 INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS - EVOLUTION & STATE POLICIES

In this section, we shall try to provide explanations for the spectacular growth in India's software exports and rapid changes in the use of IT by focusing on the role of changes in governmental policies. We shall also try to examine the problems and opportunities that software posed for the policy makers in the Indian state and what are the implications of the emphasis on software exports towards the integration of India's economy with world trade and investment patterns. Also the recognition of software as the major growth sector for earning foreign exchange in the IT Taskforce recommendations assume significant importance over here and we shall examine them in great detail.

4.1 Introduction

The term liberalisation is used to encapsulate the significant shifts in India's economic policies, shifts that have occurred on a number of fronts. The government has by altering its policies regarding trade in computer equipment, software, and FDI in information and communication activities, removed blockages to growth in the use of information technology.

Consistent with the protectionist views towards industry, India's software policies before 1984 were consistent with a model of state-led planned development. In the mid 1980s, a guided and guarded economic liberalisation took place that emphasised both greater access to imports and the promotion of software exports while still closely regulating the domestic computer and software industries. However, it became clearer in 1991 with the state slowly getting out of the way. In fact in India, economic liberalisation was combined with policies to encourage and direct the introduction, adoption, and use of information technologies and to advance national capabilities. Of particular importance in this regard are the evolution of policies:

The BJP Governments latest initiative in setting up the IT Taskforce and for the first time in India's history trying to get suggestions from the general public (using the web-site http://www.it-taskforce.com) shows governments long-term commitment towards the growth and development of this industry by following the policy of liberalisation.

4.2 A brief history in time - Software Policy prior to 1984

Over the past 45 years, Indian political and technical think tanks sought to achieve economic growth, modernisation, and industrialisation through state direction of investment and the substitution of nationally produced products and services for actual and potential imports. The Planning Commission identified priority areas for public and private investment in five-year development plans. Although the electronics and computer sectors were not emphasised as much as the role of manufacturing in Indian development plans, these areas were increasingly discussed beginning in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Following the recommendations of Bhaba Committee, the Electronics Commission and the Department of Electronics (DoE) were instituted in 1970. These became the primary agencies for the development of India's IT strategy.

The framework for software exports, which has been operational since the early 1970s, allowed the import of computers by those wishing to export software above 200% of the value of the imported computer over a period of 5 years. In 1976, the government allowed NRIs to invest in Indian software operations. If they were using foreign capital, a software export commitment of 100% of the computer's values over a period of 5 years was to be made.

In 1981, a revision of the software export policy was announced that further accentuated the emphasis on national self-reliance. Imports of computers were allowed only with proof of guaranteed exports in place. Performance and progress reports to the DoE were required every 6 months, and legal bonds were required to cover the eventuality that the schedule of export obligations was not met over the five-year period. In retrospect, one might consider that the high export requirements for imported computers might have contributed towards the "export of human resources" as a strategy to expand software exports. This essentially involved lower requirements for imports of equipment to build industry capital and infrastructure domestically in India.

4.3 1984-1990: Guided and Guarded Liberalisation

The term sea change is widely used to describe the significant policy shift that began to occur in discussions leading up to the computer policy of November 1984. Only one month after Mr. Rajiv Gandhi became the Prime Minister, the computer policy resolved a number of ongoing debates. The new policy was prompted by a number of emerging conditions in global computer services markets. The growing world demand for data processing and software services was seen to present the opportunity for Indian companies to sell computer software and services abroad. According to some, India could leapfrog the industrial age, going from being an underdeveloped agrarian economy directly to becoming an information economy in an information revolution.

The 1986 software policy had the objectives of radically expanding Indian software exports and of changing the composition of software exports. It had the following objectives:

The measures designed to facilitate the achievement of these objectives included: A number of national agencies, programs, and policies operating in a market context were initiated to facilitate the achievement of software export objectives. These included: By 1990, there were several major forms of software exports from India. The overall volume of exports of software and services during 1989-1990 was estimated to be around $110 million, up from $26 million in 1985 before the software policy was introduced. The majority of exports - around 80% - were in the form of deputations, on-site consultancy, professional services, or body shopping. Software and service exports also included projects consultancy or turkey projects - wherein the overall management of the work was in the hands of the Indian consulting firm rather than of the client - that comprised around 15% of exports. Analysts argued that further export growth were to be sought in the areas of software development based on clients' specifications, Indian based software export operations, systems maintenance and service (outside India), and training students and retraining professionals.

4.4 Industry Evaluation of Software Policy in 1990

Among the policy questions facing the Indian government were:
  1.  The appropriateness of the policy's objectives.
  2.  The importance of altering the composition of software exports.
  3.  The nature of liberalisation, government support or other policy changes required in order to achieve those objectives.

4.4.1 Appropriateness of policy's objectives

A question that was rarely considered at this point was the appropriateness of the software policy's export objectives in terms of national information technology goals. The goal of rapidly expanding exports of software and computer services via deputation was problematic in that the achievement of this goal ran the risk of eroding India's strengths and of expropriating resources away from meeting national needs and demands. Exporting software and computer services via deputation arose as a response to the demands abroad, the capabilities that Indians possessed, the lack of effective access to foreign markets, and the lower availability of information technologies in India. This helped diminish what was seen to be the Indian comparative advantage: trained and capable people. The NASSCOM set the goal of reducing the percentage of exports in deputation contracts from the 80- 85% in 1990 to around 50% by 1995. With a significant growth in exports, however, even the reduced proportion would still represent a tremendous absolute expansion in the number of people undertaking on-site work outside India.

The former head of CMC, P.D. Jain noted that to significantly expand the software exports, some of the best people would be taken away from the skilled work force available to the Indian computer services industry. Robert Schware of the World Bank in an October 1989 consultation on the world software industry in New Delhi, proposed that governmental policy should encourage the development of a public and private national industry as well as the development of a private sector export-oriented industry.
 

4.4.2 Altering the composition of Software Exports

A second policy question related to the necessity of efforts to alter the composition of software exports. Under existing conditions, a low portion of the value-added in the world software industry was captured by Indian firms, whose workers might be involved in tasks such as coding or testing software rather than in managing projects, the design of software, or the integration of different computer and software systems. Over the long term, Indian companies ran the risk of becoming stuck in the low technology and low value added activities of world software production, such as writing code or conversions of existing software programs to work with new computers or operating systems.

In 1990, a number of steps were identified by industry representatives, whereby Indian firms could shift the composition of software exports. These included:

At that time, many difficulties were recognised in efforts to alter the composition of exports. As a nascent industry, many Indian software firms lacked the necessary experience in management skills. India was also geographically remote from important world markets, making it difficult to build relations with prospective clients. However, alongside these difficulties, there were significant advantages in bringing work back to India for Indian based software export operations. These advantages included the lower costs of living and the opportunity to remain within their own culture and lower administrative costs for contracts. Large geographic distances also allowed for the remote use of clients' computing facilities via telecommunications while it was night time in the West, reducing costs and expanding the use of clients' computer resources.
 

4.4.3 Nature of liberalisation, government support or other policy changes required

Several policy changes on the part of the Indian government to allow greater access to foreign inputs such as computers, software, and training were therefore necessary to facilitate the achievement of these goals.

The areas in which the need for policy changes was especially emphasised were:

The development of stronger national and international protection for intelligence for intellectual property rights was also seen as essential to the development of the software industry. Foreign software firms that might send work to India were hesitant to do so if they could not be sure of the protection of their proprietary rights.
 

4.5 Economic Liberalisation - 1991 - 1998

Policies allowed 51% equity holdings for software companies investing in India. That is to say, changes in the rules for foreign direct investment drew capital to India and accelerated the growth of Indian-based software activities. Changes in investment rules allowed more investment by foreign software companies in production facilities in India. This created an even greater demand for trained workers and allowed expansion into new areas of software and computer services, such as providing Indian software design or data service centres for the global operations of transnational corporations. Among the US companies with software operations in India by the first half of the decade were Texas Instruments, Motorola, Hughes, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Oracle, Onward Novell and Citicorp.

The overall role of the state, thus, shifted in 1991. The new measures introduced were:

Software exports were also aided by a decline in disputes over intellectual property rights and a lessening of complaints from the international software industry.

Crucial to the deputation strategy was the receptivity of the host country to temporary workers and potentially permanent migrants. Deputation was also contingent on the ability to obtain a visa quickly in order to allow admittance for a specific worker when that worker's skills were required. In 1992-93, for instance 36% of India's software exports were in the form of on-site consultancy in the United States, and the US accounted for 58% of India's overall software exports. In 1993, electrical engineers and software workers in the US began to claim that their job openings and wage levels were being undercut by the extensive use of temporary workers by large software companies. The US Department of labour responded to these concerns in December 1994, by issuing a new set of regulations for granting visas to guest workers.

Finally the Indian software industry also benefited from the end of the Cold war. Certain restrictions on the export of information technologies, which had obstructed India's access to some computers and operating systems, were removed by the US in conjunction with dissolving the Coordinating Committee on Multilateral Exports Control (COCOM).
 

4.6 PM's IT Task force - The New IT Policy of the Government

The new BJP Government has recognised the importance of IT in India's exports. They have formulated the new IT policy via the PM's IT Task force. The IT Task Force has prepared three documents that extensively detail the evolution and the future of the Indian IT industry and also the recognition of the fact that communications infrastructure has to play an important part in the development of this industry. Here we discuss excerpts from the main policy document "Information technology Action Plan". The preamble of the policy exemplifies the Governments commitment:
 
PREAMBLE TO IT ACTION PLAN
For India, the rise of Information Technology is an opportunity to overcome historical disabilities and once again become the master of one's own national destiny. IT is a tool that will enable India to achieve the goal of becoming a strong, prosperous and self-confident nation. In doing so, IT promises to compress the time it would otherwise take for India to advance rapidly in the march of development and occupy a position of honor and pride in the comity of nations.

The Government of India has recognised the potential of Information Technology for rapid and all-round national development. The National Agenda for Governance, which is the Government's policy blueprint, has taken due note of the Information and Communication Revolution that is sweeping the globe. Accordingly, it has mandated the Government to take necessary policy and programmatic initiatives that would facilitate India's emergence as an Information Technology Superpower in the shortest possible time.

This commitment to Information and Communication Technology in the National Agenda for Governance has been forcefully articulated by Prime Minister Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee on a number of occasions. In his first televised addresss to the Nation on March 25, 1998, the Prime Minister declared that promotion of Information Technology would be one of his Government's five top priorities.

The main document of the policy highlights the important thrust areas. It goes on to say the following:
"The Government of India, recognising that the impressive growth the country has achieved since the mid-Eighties in Information Technology is still a small proportion of the potential to achieve, has resolved to make India a Global IT Superpower and a front-runner in the age of Information Revolution. The Government of India considers IT as an agent of transformation of every facet of human life which will bring about a knowledge based society in the twenty-first century. As a first step in that direction, the following revisions and additions are made to the existing Policy and Procedures for removing bottlenecks and achieving such a pre-eminent status for India."

As can be seen the thrust of the government policies (current and the future) are aimed at achieving three basic objectives:

To accomplishing these basic objectives the IT policy has made recommendations in the following areas:
  1.  Info-Infrastructure Drive: Accelerate the drive for setting up a World class Info Infrastructure with an extensive spread of Fibre Optic Networks, Satcom Networks and Wireless Networks for seamlessly interconnecting the Local Informatics Infrastructure (LII), National Informatics Infrastructure (NII) and the Global Informatics Infrastructure (GII) to ensure a fast nation-wide onset of the INTERNET, EXTRANETs and INTRANETs.
  1.  Target ITEX - 50: With a potential 2 trillion dollar Global IT industry by the year 2008, policy ambiance will be created for the Indian IT industry to target for a $ 50 billion annual export of IT Software and IT Services (including IT-enabled services) by this year, over a commensurately large domestic IT market spread all over the country.
  1.  IT for all by 2008: Accelerate the rate of PC / set-top-box penetration in the country from the 1998 level of one per 500 to one per 50 people along with a universal access to Internet / Extranets/ Intranets by the year 2008, with a flood of IT applications encompassing every walk of economic and social life of the country. The existing over 600,000 Public Telephones / Public Call Offices (PCOs) will be transformed into public tele-info- centres offering a variety of multimedia Information services. Towards the goal of IT for all by 2008, policies are provided for setting the base for a rapid spread of IT awareness among the citizens, propagation of IT literacy, networked Government, IT-led economic development, rural penetration of IT applications, training citizens in the use of day-to-day IT services like tele-banking, tele-medicine, tele-education, tele-documents transfer, tele-library, tele-info-centres, electronic commerce, Public Call Centres, among others; and training, qualitatively and quantitatively, world class IT professionals.
Now we shall discuss the main provisions that have been encapsulated under the above broad areas to achieve the objectives.

4.6.1 Info Infrastructure drive

The main policy considerations relevant for software exports under this are: The provisions no 7 and 18 essentially relate to the setting up of infrastructure for the software industry. The provisions are important in the light of the fact that it is for the first time that the Government has very clearly articulated the importance of Hi-Tech centres for the development of software industry. These hi-tech centres that would provide high quality communication links are extremely essential for the offshore development centres that contribute a bulk of software exports from India. Besides it it also important to privatise the Internet Services industry (which since been started by granting licences for the private service providers to operate) to provide high bandwidth links to the world software markets and at a competitive prices. What is now needed is to remove the monopoly of VSNL to provide international gateway services and allow the private operators to operate their own international gateways for data-transmission.

4.6.2 Target ITEX-50

For creating a congenial ambience for exporters of IT Software and IT Services (including IT enabled services) to reach the export target of US $ 50 billion by the year 2008, the following incentives shall be provided (these are discussed along with the implication of each incentive in the following pages): These sections essentially refer to the exemptions being given to the software exporters from the various controls and duties of the Government of India, which would result in their faster development. Software import duties will go that would go a long way to provide the much needed boost to the industry. Besides exempting the industry from the control of various ministries will reduce the gestation period of software projects by a lot of time thereby reducing the cost of setting up such a unit. This would reduce the time lag and help in meeting the essential delivery deadlines, which is again extremely important. Currently export can take as long as 15 days, which reduces the industry's competitiveness in delivery of software vis-à-vis other competitors. This would help a lot of companies (a large part of Indian software exports are in IT services) to plough back their earnings to their business and gain significant advantages by reducing the cost of capital. Sections 33,34 & 35 relate to the government efforts to provide working capital funds to the industry, which is an important provision because the industry has been plagued by working capital crisis for long which has hindered its growth. The government's efforts are focussed in the following directions: In the above provisions the government has finally realised that the success of IT industry is dependent on Venture Capital financing, which has been the driving force for the success of IT companies in US. This move would give a fillip to the growth of the industry and also through the return of many Indian run Californian software companies who have highlighted the absence of venture capital to be the main reason for their reluctance to invest in India. For a software industry the only tangible assets are its people and as such they must be highly rewarded to produce the levels of motivations that are needed to enhance productivity. This move recognises the importance of newer means to reward the employees in the organisation's performance by making them an owner in the firm. Also since the software industry is a global industry ownership of stocks listed in exchanges outside India is equally important. The above provisions are a removal of the most important bottleneck in the growth of the software export industry. The government has for the first time recognised that the software export industry is essentially a global industry and so useless restrictions on acquisition of development and marketing subsidiaries abroad should not be prevented. Besides Visa problems are the core issues for on-site consultancy by Indian companies and the government has for the first time announced tangible steps to tackle with this problem. These provisions relate to government's efforts to promote the Indian software industry abroad through exhibitions and the use of the internet.
 

4.6.3 IT for all by 2008

This initiative of the government is aimed at penetration of IT in terms of education and awareness. This is relevant for the Software Export industry because we need to bridge the gap in the supply and demand of well trained IT professionals in our country. Besides as is clear from the below mentioned guidelines, the government will also focus on tying up with the Indian Institutes of Management to develop managerial talent in the field of IT. This is essentially related to development of Project Management and Software Marketing skills. This is extremely important considering the fact that Indian software exporters have been accused of lacking proper managerial talent as compared to other competing countries.
 

4.6.4 Data Security Systems and Cyber Laws

The last set of regulations deals with the security aspects of the software and the use of the Internet. These laws are currently non-existent in the country but are extremely important for the development of the software industry as also the software export industry. Such laws are recognition of the long-standing need of the industry to provide a safe and secure means of data transfers over the network and also the prevention of unauthorised and pirated software.

4.7 Conclusions

The shifting role of the Indian state in promoting the growth and development of the computer software and services industry is illustrative of the limitations of a liberal economic interpretation of these policies and of the potential strengths of augmenting this with the state perspective, which focuses on the use of information and communication resources. Rather than a withdrawal of the government, significant state support for the software industry and for software exports was maintained through supportive government agencies, through training programs, and through the construction of telecommunication infrastructure to facilitate exports.

The new IT policy framed by the IT Task Force aims to address most of the long standing needs of the software industry. It is for the first time that the Government has come out with such a comprehensive document that covers nearly all the aspects of the industry. These range from financing, infrastructure and working capital needs to the penetration of IT across the length and breadth of the country and most importantly the development of a structured approach to solve the growing manpower scarcity in the industry. The aim of all these policies is to promote software export to make India a shining star in the global software scenario.
 

5 CONCLUSIONS


A comprehensive analysis of the Indian Software industry with special emphasis on the software exports can be summarised as follows:
 

6 REFERENCES

  1.  Heeks, Richard (1996) India's Software Industry - State Policy, liberalisation and industrial development
  2.  http://www.man.ac.uk/idpm/isiexpt.htm
  3.  http://www.economictimes.com/today/03feat3.htm
  4.  http://www.tagish.co.uk/ethos/news/lit1/e8ba.htm
  5.  http://www.aiia.com.au
  6.  http://www.nasscom.org
  7.  http://www.it-taskforce.com